Skip to content
UNLV Football

Paul Guenther Earned His Credit in UNLV’s Best Defensive Half Against New Mexico

A UNLV defender in white and red reaches toward a New Mexico ball carrier in teal near the sideline.

New Mexico coach Jason Eck had an explanation for why his offense stalled in Saturday’s 21-17 loss to UNLV. The Lobos expected more man coverage than they saw, and they struggled to adjust when the Rebels kept showing something else.

“They played us a little bit more zone coverage, a little bit less man coverage,” Eck said. He also described pressure coming from the field side that his staff hadn’t expected. Later, Eck acknowledged that New Mexico “never really took them out of what they wanted to do.”

I’ve been critical of Paul Guenther, and I’ve had good reasons. After Air Force, Northern Illinois and Wyoming rushed for a combined 1,021 yards against UNLV, I questioned whether Dan Mullen needed to consider giving linebackers coach Mike Scherer the defensive calls. The same problems kept appearing: running backs reaching the second level, a good snap followed by a costly mistake and opponents holding the ball when the Rebels desperately needed a stop.

Saturday gave me new evidence. New Mexico gained only 88 yards and scored three points after halftime. The Lobos managed 19 total yards in the fourth quarter as UNLV erased a 17-7 deficit, and their final three possessions ended with a three-and-out, a turnover on downs and an interception. Guenther’s defense did the work that allowed Jackson Arnold to complete the comeback and then protected the lead he gave it.

For my money, considering the opponent, the circumstances and the different stops required, that was the best half under Guenther at UNLV. His assistants and players earned their share of the credit. Giving the coordinator his doesn’t mean rewriting the first half or forgetting why his defense had been under so much scrutiny.

The opening half looked painfully familiar. Kiefer Sibley gained 22 yards on New Mexico’s first offensive snap, and he and Scottre Humphrey combined for 35 yards on the Lobos’ first three runs. Dee Crayton eventually broke through to drop Humphrey on fourth-and-1 and end that opening possession. It was a good individual response, but not yet a sign that the Rebels had the running game under control.

On New Mexico’s next possession, wide receiver Bailen George threw a 65-yard reverse pass to DJ Darling. Humphrey scored two plays later, completing an 80-yard drive in three plays. Then came a second-quarter mistake that bothered me even more. Cam Santee sacked quarterback Toa Fa’avae and helped create third-and-20. Sibley ran for 21 yards, and a hands-to-the-face penalty on Herb Gray added 10 more. New Mexico completed the possession with a nine-yard touchdown pass to tight end Cade Keith. UNLV trailed 14-0.

That third-and-20 captured the problem better than another season average could. UNLV had already forced the situation a run-heavy offense should hate. Instead of making Fa’avae throw to move the chains, the Rebels allowed Sibley to get the necessary yards on the ground. It was the kind of wasted defensive play that had made the Wyoming loss so maddening.

Santee was doing his part even during that stretch. The CW broadcast highlighted a tackle for loss in which he recognized a blocker moving toward the back side and attacked the run. He finished with a team-high 12 tackles, 2.5 for loss and a sack. UNLV had defenders who could win individual snaps; it needed to start winning enough consecutive snaps to end a drive.

The CW broadcast showed one example of the approach developing before halftime: UNLV crowded nine defenders near the line of scrimmage and left two defensive backs outside. That was one look, not evidence that the Rebels played man coverage on every snap. Eck’s postgame explanation filled in the rest. New Mexico also encountered more zone coverage than it expected, even as UNLV continued putting bodies near the run and bringing pressure from the field.

Eck wondered whether the adjustments accounted for Fa’avae’s running ability, but did not claim to know Guenther’s intentions. New Mexico had installed answers against man coverage and, Eck said, should have returned sooner to base plays that worked against both man and zone. His staff was trying to adjust during a game it had prepared for differently.

On passing downs, I also noticed UNLV sending four rushers more often than three. Against a mobile quarterback, the fourth man can narrow escape lanes once coverage forces a hesitation, provided the rushers maintain their lanes. The linebackers were better in their zone drops, keeping their eyes on Fa’avae and closing when he moved. I wouldn’t automatically call that a quarterback spy or an all-out blitz: they played their coverage assignments and reacted when he tried to run. Those were the habits missing when passing downs had turned into first downs.

The approach came with risk. On New Mexico’s first possession after halftime, Darling got behind Denver Harris on third-and-4, but Fa’avae overthrew him. A better pass might have been a touchdown. That was a missed opportunity for the Lobos, not a coverage victory for UNLV. Crowding the run and changing the coverage picture could expose the Rebels downfield, and New Mexico failed to capitalize at least once.

New Mexico also had problems protecting and communicating up front. Malik Aliane had moved from guard to center after Kaden Robnett’s injury. When right guard Jamar Tasi left, freshman Braden Chick entered, with freshman Danzel Newell already playing tackle. Aliane said UNLV’s defensive-front movement and additional pressure complicated communication. He took responsibility for getting the calls to his guards and acknowledged that New Mexico left yards on the field.

Eck agreed that the Lobos hadn’t blocked the movement well enough. He said the field-side pressure also discouraged some of the rollout plays his staff had planned in that direction, leaving New Mexico needing better answers toward the boundary. The coverage and pressure affected not only the result of individual snaps, but which plays the Lobos felt comfortable calling.

The Lobos still made UNLV work. Early in the third quarter, they put together an 11-play, nearly seven-minute drive. Humphrey broke a 20-yard run on third-and-2, and Fa’avae escaped pressure to convert fourth-and-2. But on third-and-4 near the goal line, Harris kept outside contain as Fa’avae tried to get around the edge. Santee made the tackle for no gain. Nicholas Romero kicked a 36-yard field goal, putting New Mexico ahead 17-7 with 5:36 left in the third quarter.

Harris didn’t get credit for the tackle. The CW analysts pointed out the work that made Santee’s stop possible: Harris kept outside contain and directed Fa’avae back toward the linebacker. After all the time New Mexico had used, UNLV held it to three points. The Lobos never scored again.

New Mexico finished with 203 rushing yards, 139 before halftime and 64 afterward. Fa’avae completed seven of 14 passes for 40 yards; the Lobos’ 105 team passing yards included Bailen George’s 65-yard reverse. Humphrey and Sibley had been productive enough that New Mexico didn’t have to depend on Fa’avae winning a passing contest. His limitations were visible even in victories. Guenther’s defense finally forced that test, though Fa’avae’s overthrow of Darling and the reshuffled offensive line also contributed to the result. New Mexico found itself in the situations it wanted to avoid.

Those stops became urgent when Jackson Arnold led UNLV on a 95-yard touchdown drive. Peyton Zachary kept the possession alive with a 22-yard reception on third-and-9, and Arnold found Kayden McGee for a 43-yard score. The Rebels were within 17-14 with 11:40 remaining, but New Mexico still had the lead and a running game that could have drained the clock.

Andre Porter ended that possibility in three snaps. On first down, he sacked Fa’avae for a four-yard loss. On second down, Porter and Santee stopped Sibley two yards behind the line. The Lobos handed off to Humphrey on third-and-16 and gained only three yards, with Gray and Crayton finishing the tackle. New Mexico punted after losing three yards on the possession.

Earlier, a sack had been followed by Sibley’s 21-yard run on third-and-20. This time, Porter’s sack led to another tackle for loss and then a punt. UNLV finally followed one good defensive snap with two more.

Arnold took advantage of the possession. He connected with McGee for 21 yards and later broke loose for a 44-yard touchdown run on third-and-10. He explained in his postgame interview that the play wasn’t simply a designed quarterback draw; he recognized movement up front and took the option to run. UNLV led 21-17 with 7:26 left. The offense earned those points, but the defense had given it the ball back quickly enough to make the comeback possible.

New Mexico got favorable field position on the ensuing kickoff return and moved into Rebels territory. Kamuela Ka’aihue met Sibley for no gain on second-and-7 at the UNLV 46. Porter then brought down Fa’avae after a four-yard scramble, leaving fourth-and-3 at the UNLV 42.

Eck tried to free Keith with a route that began as though the tight end were blocking. He said afterward that Keith gained a step but the defender recovered. The CW broadcast credited Avery Helm for staying with the play. The throw fell incomplete with 3:53 left.

Helm didn’t get an interception or a credited pass breakup, but his coverage ended the drive. New Mexico had tried to punish an aggressive defender by disguising Keith’s release. Helm stayed with him and forced Fa’avae to make a difficult throw. It was a crucial contribution in a game people will remember for Arnold’s run.

UNLV’s offense couldn’t run out the remaining clock, leaving the defense one final assignment. Matthew Choules hit a 50-yard punt, and Kyron Chambers stopped Marco Beltran Jr. at the New Mexico 3 with 2:43 left. After a first down and a false start, Elias Rudolph sacked Fa’avae for five yards. On the next snap, facing second-and-20, Fa’avae threw the pass Tony-Louis Nkuba intercepted. The catch stood after replay review, ending the Lobos’ last chance. Field position, pressure and coverage had each played a part in securing the win.

North Dakota State provides a serious counterargument to my assessment. UNLV shut out the Bison after halftime in a 13-7 win Oct. 10, intercepted three passes overall and got its only touchdown on Porter’s pick-six. That was an excellent defensive performance.

I put Albuquerque ahead of it because New Mexico entered 8-1, ranked No. 23 and riding an 11-game home winning streak. After trailing most of the night, UNLV needed several distinct late stops to finish the upset. That’s my judgment about the circumstances, not a claim that a single statistic settles the comparison.

Eck’s account establishes what New Mexico struggled against, not who called each UNLV defensive play. There is no verified evidence that Scherer took over the calls, and I’m not going to manufacture it because the defense improved. Scherer and the other assistants have responsibilities within this staff, while players such as Porter, Santee, Ka’aihue, Helm, Rudolph and Nkuba made the stops. Guenther is the coordinator responsible for the unit and deserves to be evaluated on the result it produced.

Guenther still has to address the first half. UNLV cannot afford to fall behind by 14 before its run fits, tackling and pressure start producing consecutive stops. San José State will test whether that discipline carries into the next game. Albuquerque’s finish doesn’t erase the rushing problems against Air Force, Northern Illinois and Wyoming.

I wanted Guenther held accountable when UNLV couldn’t get off the field. After Albuquerque, that standard works in his favor: his defense made the stops that beat a ranked opponent, and he earned the credit.